The Ultimate Showdown: Comparing the Best Lifejackets for Sport Fishing

In Gear by admin

When it comes to sport fishing, safety should always be a top priority. One essential piece of safety equipment that every angler should have is a reliable lifejacket. With a plethora of options available, finding the best lifejacket can be a daunting task. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll take a closer look at three top contenders that promise to keep anglers safe on the water: the Mustang Survival Elite 28 Inflatable PFD, the Onyx A/M-24 Automatic/Manual Inflatable Life Jacket, and the Stohlquist Edge Life Jacket.

1. Mustang Survival Elite 28 Inflatable PFD:

Description: The Mustang Survival Elite 28 Inflatable PFD is designed with anglers in mind, offering a comfortable and unobtrusive fit. It features an automatic inflation system that can be activated upon immersion in water or a manual pull-tab for added control. The slim profile of this lifejacket allows anglers to move freely while casting and reeling in those prized catches.


  • Lightweight and low profile, providing unhindered movement during fishing activities.
  • Automatic or manual inflation options give anglers a sense of security in any situation.
  • Equipped with a durable outer shell and a comfortable neoprene collar.
  • Integrated harness loops for anglers who prefer additional safety attachments.
  • Comes with a secure pocket to store essential items such as a small tackle box or a knife.


  • The CO2 cartridge needs regular inspection and replacement, adding to maintenance costs.
  • Not suitable for individuals who are not comfortable with inflatable lifejackets or those who dislike wearing them for extended periods.

2. Onyx A/M-24 Automatic/Manual Inflatable Life Jacket:

Description: The Onyx A/M-24 is a versatile lifejacket with a combination of automatic and manual inflation capabilities. The sleek design ensures minimal bulk, granting anglers ease of movement on deck. The bright-colored exterior enhances visibility, making it easier for rescue teams to locate wearers in an emergency.


  • Dual inflation options offer flexibility and reassurance for anglers of all comfort levels.
  • Soft neoprene neckline ensures comfort during extended wear.
  • Comes with a handy zippered pocket for storing small tools or personal items.
  • Easy to re-arm after deployment, making it reusable for multiple outings.


  • Some anglers may find the collar slightly uncomfortable during hot weather.
  • The slim profile might not provide enough buoyancy for individuals who are not strong swimmers.
  • Regular maintenance and CO2 cartridge replacement are necessary.

3. Stohlquist Edge Life Jacket:

Description: The Stohlquist Edge Life Jacket is a reliable choice for anglers seeking a traditional, non-inflatable option. It features a durable 500-denier Cordura outer shell and adjustable padded shoulder straps, providing comfort and security during fishing trips.


  • No need to worry about CO2 cartridge maintenance or inflating the jacket in an emergency.
  • Multiple adjustment points ensure a snug fit for various body types.
  • Large armholes offer unimpeded arm movement, ideal for casting and reeling.
  • Integrated pockets for storing fishing gear, tools, and personal items.


  • Bulky design may restrict some movement compared to inflatable alternatives.
  • Reduced ventilation may cause discomfort in hot weather conditions.
  • While inherently buoyant, it may not provide the same buoyancy as inflatable models.

Conclusion: Choosing the best lifejacket for sport fishing largely depends on individual preferences and comfort levels. The Mustang Survival Elite 28 Inflatable PFD excels in providing maximum mobility, while the Onyx A/M-24 strikes a balance between inflatability and traditional design. For anglers who prefer a conventional lifejacket, the Stohlquist Edge offers the required buoyancy with plenty of storage options.

Ultimately, the ideal lifejacket is one that you are willing to wear consistently, ensuring your safety while enjoying your sport fishing adventures. Remember, no matter which lifejacket you choose, its proper usage and regular maintenance are crucial for your safety on the water. Tight lines and stay safe out there!